And with its peppermint bark flavor, this is where we arrive at the first classic peppermint ice cream profile. Favorite Day's very fluffy body glides into a fairly smooth texture as it melts.

These ten pints of peppermint ice cream, peppermint stick ice cream, and peppermint bark ice cream have all the flavor and texture you could ever want when it comes to the best peppermint ice cream.

Peppermint ice cream in a bowl, garnished with fresh mint and hard candy, surrounded by candy canes and ornaments - Rimma Bondarenko/Shutterstock I tried orange chicken from Trader Joe's ...