Mariah Carey extended her Celebration of Mimi Live ... and critics claims she looked rather “stiff” while singing her hit ...

Discover Mariah Carey’s greatest hits. Hear the timeless songs that showcase her incredible vocal range, from soulful ballads to upbeat anthems.

She was getting her whole life at the Mariah Carey concert.” Others saw the clip as a full-circle moment for Riri, who has never shied away from her love of the “Shake it Off” singer.